Two ways to develop children’s synoptic view of a conversation

M.M. McCabe (2006) characterises (Platonic) dialectic as having the following five dimensions:

  1. logical dimension (A or B, A or not A etc.)
  2. sequential dimension (doing things in the right order)
  3. psychological dimension (problem seeing)
  4. An epistemological dimension (aiming towards a synoptic view of the discussion)
  5. normative dimension (doing it well or doing it badly)

 

I have previously written that having children gain a synoptic view (dimension 4) – or getting a sense of the conversation as a whole (where it’s been, where it’s going, what the implications are, what progress has been made etc.) – is one of the most difficult things to achieve in a philosophical conversation between children and that this is the characteristic that most distinguishes philosophy with children from philosophy with adults. However, here are two simple, practical ways that you can use to help encourage children’s synoptic view of a conversation.

 

Socratic Circle

If you are not already familiar with SCs then have a look at wikipedia: 'Socratic Circles'.

To implement this in a basic way during a class discussion, simply put two or more students into the ‘outer circle’ role. Have them sit out of the circle with a pen and paper and ask them to listen to the discussion and make their own notes regarding the conversation. Periodically, ask them to comment on the discussion, either with a broad question like, ‘What do you think of the discussion so far?’ or with more specific tasks such as, ‘Do you agree/disagree with anyone?’ or ‘Are there any arguments you found persuasive?’ etc.

 

Scribing and summarising

Appoint a scribe/summariser. Ask someone to ‘concept/topic/mind-map’ the discussion (find out more on wikipedia: 'Concept Map'), as it happens, on a large whiteboard so it can be seen by all the children. Periodically, ask the ‘scribe’ to summarise the discussion so far. In order to engage the rest of the class with this way of developing their synoptic view, once the scribe has finished, ask the whole class whether they think anything important has been left out from the scribe’s summary (interpretative), or ask them if they agree with it (evaluative). You could try out other ways of making use of this such as asking the class, ‘Where do you think we should go next?’ (strategical) or ‘What do you think we should do to solve this problem?’ or ‘Have we answered the question?’ (progress-orientated) etc. Some of these suggestions combine the Socratic Circle approach with the Scribe strategy.

 

What do you think?

Why don’t you try out these strategies and let us know (in a comment on this page) how it went. Did it help to encourage children’s synoptic view?

Posted by Joe Tyler on 10th January 2017 at 12:00am

Comments

https://www.youube.me/ - 온라인바카라,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,바카라게임사이트,인터넷카지노 https://youube.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youube.me/ - 카지노주소 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youube.me/royalcasinoseries/ - 로얄카지노계열 https://youube.me/slotmachinesite/ - 슬롯머신사이트 https://youube.me/maxcasino/ - 맥스카지노 https://youube.me/baccaratgamesite/ - 바카라게임사이트 https://youube.me/casimbakorea-casino/ - 카심바코리아 카지노 https://youube.me/mobilecasino/ - 모바일카지노 https://youube.me/real-timebaccarat/ - 실시간바카라 https://youube.me/livecasino/ - 라이브카지노 https://youube.me/onlineslots/ - 온라인슬롯 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 바카라 이기는방법 https://youube.me/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://youube.me/ourcasinosite/ - 우리카지노사이트 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 샌즈카지노주소 https://youube.me/baccarat-rulesofthegame/ - 바카라 게임규칙 https://youube.me/baccarat-howtoplay/ - 바카라 게임방법 gamja888.com instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.youube.me/ - 카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 03:28am

https://www.youubbe.me/ - 카지노사이트,슬롯사이트,바카라사이트,온라인카지노,카지노주소 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 안전한카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 슬롯카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 바카라게임 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노추천 https://youubbe.me/ - 비바카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youubbe.me/casinosite/ - 카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/baccarat/ - 바카라 https://youubbe.me/baccaratsite/ - 바카라사이트 https://youubbe.me/pharaoh-casino/ - 파라오카지노 https://youubbe.me/제왕카지노/ - 제왕카지노 https://youubbe.me/mgm카지노/ - mgm카지노 https://youubbe.me/theking-casino/ - 더킹카지노 https://youubbe.me/coin-casino/ - 코인카지노 https://youubbe.me/solaire-casino/ - 솔레어카지노 https://youubbe.me/casino-game/ - 카지노게임 https://youubbe.me/micro-gaming/ - 마이크로게이밍 https://youubbe.me/asia-gaming/ - 아시아게이밍 https://youubbe.me/taisan-gaming/ - 타이산게이밍 https://youubbe.me/oriental-game/ - 오리엔탈게임 https://youubbe.me/evolution-game/ - 에볼루션게임 https://youubbe.me/dragon-tiger/ - 드래곤타이거 https://youubbe.me/dream-gaming/ - 드림게이밍 https://youubbe.me/vivo-gaming/ - 비보게이밍 youube.me gamja888.com instagrme.com Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://youubbe.me/ - 엠카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 03:29am

온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 https://youube.me/ https://instagrme.com/ https://youubbe.me/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://instagrme.com/ - 카지노게임사이트 on 8th April 2022 at 03:31am

https://www.gamja888.com/ - 온라인카지노,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,온라인바카라,카지노게임사이트,Gamja888 https://gamja888.com/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://gamja888.com/ - 맥스카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 비바카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 카지노주소 https://gamja888.com/ - 바카라추천 https://gamja888.com/onlinebaccarat/ - 온라인바카라 https://gamja888.com/millionclubcasino/ - 밀리언클럽카지노 https://gamja888.com/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/baccaratsiterecommendation/ - 바카라사이트추천 https://gamja888.com/ourcasino/ - 우리카지노계열 https://gamja888.com/slotmachine777/ - 슬롯머신777 https://gamja888.com/royalcasinosite/ - 로얄카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/crazyslot/ - 크레이지슬롯 https://gamja888.com/onlineblackjack/ - 온라인블랙잭 https://gamja888.com/internetroulette/ - 인터넷룰렛 https://gamja888.com/casinoverificationsite/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://gamja888.com/safebaccaratsite/ - 안전바카라사이트 https://gamja888.com/mobilebaccarat/ - 모바일바카라 https://gamja888.com/howtowin-baccarat/ - 바카라 필승법 https://gamja888.com/meritcasino/ - 메리트카지노 https://gamja888.com/baccarat-howto/ - 바카라 노하우 youube.me instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.gamja888.com/ - 온라인 다이사이 on 8th April 2022 at 03:32am

https://politicadeverdade.com/ 안전놀이터 If the media's claim is true, Tottenham fans will be really tired. Paris Saint-Germain won the Ligue 1 title with an overwhelming record of 24 wins, 6 draws and 4 losses. However, inside the club, he is known

Posted by 안전놀이터 on 11th May 2022 at 04:55am

메이저사이트 Tottenham, on the other hand, is currently ranked fifth in the English Premier League with 18 wins, 4 draws and 11 losses with five games left this season. In fact, the battle for first place was narrowed down

Posted by 메이저사이트 on 11th May 2022 at 04:56am

https://politicadeverdade.com/mtgeomjung/ 먹튀검증 Chelsea, ranked third, also has 65 points, making it a stable place to advance to the UEFA Champions League. After all, it is a battle between Tottenham and Arsenal, the "North London rivals." Arsenal are ranked

Posted by 먹튀검증 on 11th May 2022 at 05:08am

https://scottchasserot.com/ 먹튀검증 However, there was a report that the head coach would throw the baton on his own, especially when it was not enough to focus on the ranking fight right now. It doesn't seem strange at all even if the team

Posted by 먹튀검증 on 11th May 2022 at 05:08am

https://nakedemperornews.com/ 안전놀이터 No coach from around the world will stop the club's poor decline," he said. At the time, Conte said, "The club replaces the head coach, but the players are always the same. The results do not change.

Posted by 안전놀이터 on 11th May 2022 at 05:09am

https://joelecorbeau.com/ 안전놀이터 It's really frustrating. If I have to take responsibility, I think I have to take responsibility. I have to talk to the club. And I will accept all the decisions the club makes," he said, hinting at his resignation.

Posted by 안전놀이터 on 11th May 2022 at 05:09am

https://nyrthos.com/ 먹튀검증커뮤니티 Tottenham will play the 34th round of the league's home game against Leicester City at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium at 11 p.m. on the 30th. Attention is focusing on how Conte will lead the game and set the

Posted by 먹튀검증커뮤니티 on 11th May 2022 at 05:09am

https://www.totosinsa.com/ 먹튀검증커뮤니티 Liverpool beat Everton 2-0 in the 34th round of the "2021-2022 Premier League" at Anfield in Liverpool, England, on the morning of the 25th. Liverpool, who scored 79 points, put pressure on the leader Manchester

Posted by 먹튀검증커뮤니티 on 11th May 2022 at 05:10am