...Versus Thinking

Here's Steve's response to both David's and Pete's ideas on confident thinking, critical thinking and the possibility of finding a 'third way'.

Versus Thinking

By Steve Hoggins

The importance of teaching critical thinking can be overstated. Though recent political events determine that it has been understated in many areas. The post-truth politics headlines suggested that critical thinking has failed to poke through the holes of Trumpist/Brexiteers’s poorly structured arguments. However, this hole-poking might be part of the problem.

The campaigns of Trump and Brexit brought out many voters, a number that no one expected. It seems they hadn’t spoken out before, not tried to explain their ideas, simply walked quietly into polling stations in their masses and made decisions without bothering to engage in the critical thinking that educators urge us to all teach.

Critical thinking is a double edge sword, though. For those that have the confidence and education it means one can build structures of thought that are coherent and withstand a certain amount of testing. It’s never completely secure, though. The field of science, for example, constantly revises its view of the world considering new arguments for theories, and inviting criticism from others (ideally). So for many, critical thinking is destabilising. It upsets their assumptions and undermined their beliefs about the world, and that can be terrifying.

So perhaps we need them to be confident thinkers. Confident enough to withstand the criticism and like the good philosopher: re-evaluate their views. As I sit here writing, this sounds like an ideal combination. If we all had the resilience and grit to enter an intellectual area, where we are prepared to take hits to our structured thinking and rebuild if necessary, we would be able to make good decisions. However, the suggestion of how it ought to be is a bit too far removed from how it is.

The general incredulity, mine included, at people’s reasons for voting in absurd people and ideas, suggests that there are swathes of people not thinking critically. My experience in teaching adults and children tells me that critical thinking makes people nervous unless you have high-quality relationships and have set up a respectful space to dialogue. Another key element is the exploratory element.

Children often propose ridiculous arguments. Adults do it too, as I have just mentioned, but with children I have never told them their argument is ridiculous. There are good reasons for this A) ‘Ridiculous’ is no kind of argument, B) They don’t have the confidence to stand up to criticism and C) They fall silent and stop thinking. If I point out the holes in a child’s argument, through explicit stating it or leading question, the response is the same – silence.

‘BE CONFIDENT!’ I want to shout at them. This of course wouldn’t work either. If I want to engage them with better thinking (which may include being confident and being critical) I have to first engage with their ideas, try to see what they are saying, view their ideas favourably and see how far they can go.

I find this works with adults too and it is far more interesting. Critical discussions are ones that invite you to destroy assumptions, challenge propositions and generally reduce another’s, less than perfectly structured ideas, to rubble. Great for truth seeking in an environment where everyone understands the need for rigor and is prepared to be wrong. Not so good for making people think, especially young people and Trump voters.

Curious conversations make less progress towards the truth. They invite people to say what they want without thinking it through. Assumptions are largely left unchallenged and propositions are entertained. The interlocutors are not trying to seek the holes in each other’s thinking, but rather trying to see the whole of each other’s thinking. I love these conversations. Being wrong feels quite comfortable and that is something that helps me to fully flesh out my initially incoherent thoughts. Furthermore, the style of interaction makes later criticism easier to take – ‘Well she has been so generous in trying to comprehend my other ideas, I feel in a better position to take a challenge’. This then feeds my resilience and I go on to be able to take larger and larger hits to my thinking, without crumbling and falling silent.

So I think Pete Worley and David Birch are right when they write about the need for critical and confident thinking, respectively. What I would suggest is that we start with a kind of curious way of thinking, so that we can introduce the confidence and the criticism.

You don’t have to hug Brexit/Trump voters, just get them to open up a bit; see what’s inside.

You can poke holes in it later.

If you haven't read them already...

Take a look at Pete's original article by clicking on this link to the Innovate My School website, and David's article on 'Critical Thinking vs Confident Thinking' by clicking the link below.

Posted by Joe Tyler on 12th December 2016 at 12:00am

Comments

Curious conversations open up many possibilities, and allowance of asking more questions, is that reasoned or not ?

Posted by Bill Mc Allister on 14th December 2016 at 11:19am

온라인바카라 카지노사이트 바카라사이트 인터넷카지노 바카라게임사이트 퀸즈슬롯 카지노주소 카지노검증사이트 로얄카지노계열 슬롯머신사이트 맥스카지노 바카라게임사이트 카심바코리아 카지노 모바일카지노 실시간바카라 라이브카지노 온라인슬롯 바카라 이기는방법 안전카지노사이트 우리카지노사이트 샌즈카지노주소 바카라 게임규칙 바카라 게임방법 온라인바카라 카지노사이트 바카라사이트 인터넷카지노 바카라게임사이트 퀸즈슬롯 카지노주소 카지노검증사이트 로얄카지노계열 슬롯머신사이트 맥스카지노 바카라게임사이트 카심바코리아 카지노 모바일카지노 실시간바카라 라이브카지노 온라인슬롯 바카라 이기는방법 안전카지노사이트 우리카지노사이트 샌즈카지노주소 바카라 게임규칙 바카라 게임방법 https://gamja888.com/ https://instagrme.com/ https://youubbe.me/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://Instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://www.youube.me/ - 슬롯카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 03:18am

카지노사이트 슬롯사이트 온라인카지노 카지노주소 카지노검증사이트 안전한카지노사이트 슬롯카지노 바카라게임 카지노추천 비바카지노 퀸즈슬롯 카지노사이트 바카라 바카라사이트 파라오카지노 제왕카지노 mgm카지노 더킹카지노 코인카지노 솔레어카지노 카지노게임 마이크로게이밍 아시아게이밍 타이산게이밍 오리엔탈게임 에볼루션게임 드래곤타이거 드림게이밍 비보게이밍 카지노사이트 슬롯사이트 온라인카지노 카지노주소 카지노검증사이트 안전한카지노사이트 슬롯카지노 바카라게임 카지노추천 비바카지노 퀸즈슬롯 카지노사이트 바카라 바카라사이트 파라오카지노 제왕카지노 mgm카지노 더킹카지노 코인카지노 솔레어카지노 카지노게임 마이크로게이밍 아시아게이밍 타이산게이밍 오리엔탈게임 에볼루션게임 드래곤타이거 드림게이밍 비보게이밍 https://youube.me/ https://gamja888.com/ https://instagrme.com/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://Instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://youubbe.me/ - 온라인 카지노 슬롯머신 on 8th April 2022 at 03:19am

바카라사이트 온라인바카라 실시간바카라 퀸즈슬롯 바카라게임 카지노주소 우리카지노 더킹카지노 샌즈카지노 예스카지노 코인카지노 더나인카지노 더존카지노 카지노사이트 골드카지노 에볼루션카지노 카지노 슬롯게임 baccarat 텍사스 홀덤 포카 blackjack 바카라사이트 온라인바카라 실시간바카라 퀸즈슬롯 바카라게임 카지노주소 우리카지노 더킹카지노 샌즈카지노 예스카지노 코인카지노 더나인카지노 더존카지노 카지노사이트 골드카지노 에볼루션카지노 카지노 슬롯게임 baccarat 텍사스 홀덤 포카 blackjack https://youube.me/ https://gamja888.com/ https://youubbe.me/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://Instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://instagrme.com/ - 로터스게이밍 on 8th April 2022 at 03:20am

온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 https://youube.me/ https://instagrme.com/ https://youubbe.me/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://Instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://www.gamja888.com/ - 33카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 03:20am

Ahaa, its good discussion about this post here at this webpage, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting here. 사설 카지노 제이나인 제이나인 소셜 카지노 카지노 게임 종류 제이나인 제이나인 카지노 먹튀 검증 호텔 카지노 제이나인 https://www.j9korea.com/

Posted by Aira on 28th December 2022 at 07:32am