In out, in out, shake it all about

The Philosophical Triangle

Screen Shot 2016-09-29 at 13.42.30

On The Philosophy Foundation blog recently, we have seen posts by Pete Worley on the Hokey Kokey method, and Steven Campbell-Harris on his Kokey Hokey Method. 

These interesting posts remind me of a diagram I have often drawn on the board when working with teachers who I was training in P4C. I'm not a great one for making up names for techniques, diagrams and the like (I guess I have a lingering suspicion of this from reading de Bono). But I had to call the picture below something, so I have called it a 'foci triangle' (see, I told you I wasn't very good at clever names).

Here's the idea. Both Pete's Hokey Kokey and Steven's Kokey Hokey talk about a two way movement between the more abstract and the more particular. In Pete’s example, the particular is a specific historical event (the Vietnam War) and its associated concrete question Was the ‘domino theory’ a good reason for the Americans to go to war in Vietnam? Although Steven also talks about this abstract-particular movement, he has in mind the particularities of the students' own experience of the world: how they use and understand words. 

In my diagram, there is a three way movement: between the abstract ideas/concepts/discussions, the particularities of the specific situation that is the trigger for the discussion (be it a story, dialogue, newspaper article, concrete question, historical event…), and the particularities of the students' own lived experiences. 

The first of these three categories is what makes the discussion recognizably philosophical, of course. I guess we have all seen communities of inquiry where the discussion seldom or never visits this realm. 

The second category provides a common experience for the community, so that they are all focused together on a common inquiry. This is why Matthew Lipman was so insistent that his stories be read in common around the class. The particular experience embodied in the trigger is often also somewhat neutral - no one student is emotionally invested in it, and so it can provide a non-threatening ground for testing out the abstract ideas.

The third category is where the discussion becomes connected to each student's own understanding of the world. Here, students are constructing understanding through connecting  what they know to the new (or, at times, reconstructing the old to fit in with the new). Here, for example, is where the power of anecdotes lies, provided those anecdotes are connected to the first two categories. 

For a community of inquiry to get bogged down in any one of these categories has dangers. Being stuck in the abstract risks disengagement and the ‘what’s the use of all this’ question. Concentrating merely on the trigger experience means that the inquiry remains in a disciplinary context: literary critique, psychological conjecture, historical investigation or the like. To remain in the lived experiences of the students involves an endless swapping of anecdotes and stories that lack any purpose beyond hearing the experiences of others.

I have always thought it useful to make this distinction between the two types of particularities, so teachers can pay attention to both, as well as the abstract philosophical realm. The triangle gives teachers a structure for thinking about what interventions or questions in the discussion can help the students to move between the three categories, and thus bind the discussion into a holistic philosophical dialogue that makes a difference to students’ learning and way of operating in the world.

Tim Sprod is author of Discussions in Science and Philosophical Discussions in Moral Education.

Posted by Emma Worley on 29th September 2016 at 12:00am

Comments

https://www.youube.me/ - 온라인바카라,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,바카라게임사이트,인터넷카지노 https://youube.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youube.me/ - 카지노주소 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youube.me/royalcasinoseries/ - 로얄카지노계열 https://youube.me/slotmachinesite/ - 슬롯머신사이트 https://youube.me/maxcasino/ - 맥스카지노 https://youube.me/baccaratgamesite/ - 바카라게임사이트 https://youube.me/casimbakorea-casino/ - 카심바코리아 카지노 https://youube.me/mobilecasino/ - 모바일카지노 https://youube.me/real-timebaccarat/ - 실시간바카라 https://youube.me/livecasino/ - 라이브카지노 https://youube.me/onlineslots/ - 온라인슬롯 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 바카라 이기는방법 https://youube.me/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://youube.me/ourcasinosite/ - 우리카지노사이트 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 샌즈카지노주소 https://youube.me/baccarat-rulesofthegame/ - 바카라 게임규칙 https://youube.me/baccarat-howtoplay/ - 바카라 게임방법 gamja888.com instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.youube.me/ - 온라인카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 06:32am

https://www.youubbe.me/ - 카지노사이트,슬롯사이트,바카라사이트,온라인카지노,카지노주소 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 안전한카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 슬롯카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 바카라게임 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노추천 https://youubbe.me/ - 비바카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youubbe.me/casinosite/ - 카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/baccarat/ - 바카라 https://youubbe.me/baccaratsite/ - 바카라사이트 https://youubbe.me/pharaoh-casino/ - 파라오카지노 https://youubbe.me/제왕카지노/ - 제왕카지노 https://youubbe.me/mgm카지노/ - mgm카지노 https://youubbe.me/theking-casino/ - 더킹카지노 https://youubbe.me/coin-casino/ - 코인카지노 https://youubbe.me/solaire-casino/ - 솔레어카지노 https://youubbe.me/casino-game/ - 카지노게임 https://youubbe.me/micro-gaming/ - 마이크로게이밍 https://youubbe.me/asia-gaming/ - 아시아게이밍 https://youubbe.me/taisan-gaming/ - 타이산게이밍 https://youubbe.me/oriental-game/ - 오리엔탈게임 https://youubbe.me/evolution-game/ - 에볼루션게임 https://youubbe.me/dragon-tiger/ - 드래곤타이거 https://youubbe.me/dream-gaming/ - 드림게이밍 https://youubbe.me/vivo-gaming/ - 비보게이밍 youube.me gamja888.com instagrme.com Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://youubbe.me/ - 온라인 슬롯추천 on 8th April 2022 at 06:33am

온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 온라인카지노 카지노사이트 카지노게임사이트 바카라사이트 퀸즈슬롯 맥스카지노 비바카지노 카지노주소 바카라추천 온라인바카라 밀리언클럽카지노 안전카지노사이트 바카라사이트추천 우리카지노계열 슬롯머신777 로얄카지노사이트 크레이지슬롯 온라인블랙잭 인터넷룰렛 카지노검증사이트 안전바카라사이트 모바일바카라 바카라 필승법 메리트카지노 바카라 노하우 https://youube.me/ https://instagrme.com/ https://youubbe.me/ https://Instagrm.me/ https://instagrme.net/ https://instagrme.site/ https://instagrme.live/ https://naverom.me/ http://facebookom.me/

Posted by https://instagrme.com/ - 바카라 배팅전략 on 8th April 2022 at 06:34am

https://www.gamja888.com/ - 온라인카지노,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,온라인바카라,카지노게임사이트,Gamja888 https://gamja888.com/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://gamja888.com/ - 맥스카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 비바카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 카지노주소 https://gamja888.com/ - 바카라추천 https://gamja888.com/onlinebaccarat/ - 온라인바카라 https://gamja888.com/millionclubcasino/ - 밀리언클럽카지노 https://gamja888.com/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/baccaratsiterecommendation/ - 바카라사이트추천 https://gamja888.com/ourcasino/ - 우리카지노계열 https://gamja888.com/slotmachine777/ - 슬롯머신777 https://gamja888.com/royalcasinosite/ - 로얄카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/crazyslot/ - 크레이지슬롯 https://gamja888.com/onlineblackjack/ - 온라인블랙잭 https://gamja888.com/internetroulette/ - 인터넷룰렛 https://gamja888.com/casinoverificationsite/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://gamja888.com/safebaccaratsite/ - 안전바카라사이트 https://gamja888.com/mobilebaccarat/ - 모바일바카라 https://gamja888.com/howtowin-baccarat/ - 바카라 필승법 https://gamja888.com/meritcasino/ - 메리트카지노 https://gamja888.com/baccarat-howto/ - 바카라 노하우 youube.me instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.gamja888.com/ - 코인카지노 on 8th April 2022 at 06:35am