Peter Worley | A philosophical enquiry strategy for up-against-it secondary school teachers
I train a lot of teachers in questioning and enquiry techniques both for use in philosophy sessions with their classes but also for use in their normal curriculum teaching. I often witness enthusiasm for the techniques during the training, however, especially with secondary school teachers, I also often see a big drop off of enthusiasm after the training. One major reason I have identified is to do with a perceived lack of immediate relevance. So, during the training the teachers really see the value of the kinds of enquiry skills that I teach, but when under pressure to meet the demands of exams and coursework, the same teachers very often don’t see that they have time for these enriching – but time consuming – discussions.
I recently had an experience of exactly this kind of attitude-shift when I went to observe a secondary teacher who, as part of his training in enquiry and questioning strategies with me, had me visit his classroom to observe him deliver an enquiry session. By the end, however, the same teacher had an epiphany about how the enquiry techniques were much more relevant than he’d at first thought. He said to me, ‘This is what my colleagues need to know about how this philosophy stuff works.’ Then he added, ‘This’ll sell it.’ So, in this piece, I thought that I’d share what happened in order to make a case that running enquiries with your class is relevant and worth the time it takes out of your lessons – and that it’s also relevant to secondary teachers who find themselves up against it.
First of all, just to highlight how ‘up against it’ the teacher was, he’d forgotten that I was visiting at all! After apologizing, he took me to his classroom where about ten students, girls and boys, preparing for their history GCSE were sitting. On the board was this image:
With this question underneath:
Was the ‘domino theory’ a good reason for the Americans to go to war in Vietnam?
He was about to scrap the lesson so that he could run the philosophy session he was planning to run (from my book) for the observation. I looked at what was on the board and, with an eye on making my presence in some way relevant, I said to him, ‘Why don’t you run the session around what you’re doing?’ In a brief discussion with him about how to do a philosophy session around this, I said, ‘Well, one way to approach this is to abstract a little from the more concrete question you have on the board. So, maybe something like ‘When, if ever, is it okay to go to war?’’ With a philosophical strategy I have developed called the ‘Hokey Kokey Method’ in mind, I suggested he start with his question – the one already on the board – and then move to the abstract question, returning to the concrete afterwards. He agreed and proceeded to commence his session.
Here’s the Hokey Kokey Method (in, out then in again) structure in brief:
- Start with a concrete question: e.g. ‘Are the children [in the story] free?’
- Move to an abstract question(s): e.g. ‘What is freedom? What is a child?’
- Return to the concrete question, testing the concrete against the abstract and the abstract against the concrete: e.g. ‘So, if freedom is… and a child is… then are the children [in the story] free?’
He chose to begin his session by ‘unpacking’ the image, which I thought was an excellent way to start (at The Philosophy Foundation, we would employ what we call a ‘hermeneutic question’, which means a question that aims to have the students interpret, or ‘unpack’ an image or text etc. For instance, ‘What is meant by X?’ or ‘What do you think X means?’). However, he displayed all the usual teacher tendencies to lead the interpretation himself, either by filling silences with his own interpretation or by asking leading questions that included ‘the right’ interpretation. As a brief aside, I recommended to him – and will do so now – for unpacking images, a strategy known as ‘Visual Thinking Strategies’ (VTS) which can be found described in detail in a book called Visual Thinking Strategies by Philip Yenawine. The basic idea is that you allow the class to come to the image naively and work out from there with simple questions like ‘What do you see?’, ‘What do you think that might mean?’, ‘Why do you think X is there?’ etc.
After he had spent a short time unpacking the image he then moved to his question, at which point his questioning style changed completely. He began to use the techniques I had shared on the training course, passing the ball to speakers, limiting his responses to simple opening-up questions such as ‘Can you say more about that?’, ‘What do you mean by…?’, ‘Can you give an example?’ etc. Then he moved to the abstract question, ‘When, if ever, is it okay to go to war?’ I could see in his face and his demeanour that he felt it was no longer relevant; that the discussion, interesting though it was, had now turned into something that he couldn’t see impacting valuably on his lesson time. One of the students said, ‘It’s okay to go to war if it’s self defense.’ The teacher took the ball to pass to another student. I wanted to demonstrate how the Hokey Kokey Method works, so I intervened; I turned to the student who had just spoken, and using a technique I call ‘iffing and anchoring’ I said, ‘So, if it’s okay to go to war in self defense, does the domino theory appeal to self defense?’ (This technique ‘ifs’ what has been said and then links it (‘anchors’ it) back to a main question.) ‘In a way it does, because…’ said the student. I have already ascertained from the group that they were unanimous in their view that America was not justified going to war in Vietnam on the basis of the domino theory. One student had said that self defense was one reason why it might be justified and had now reconsidered the domino theory to be, in some way, a self defense justification.
This was the point at which the penny dropped. Suddenly he saw how, using the Hokey Kokey method, a philosophical enquiry could directly impact on a non-philosophical discussion and how the abstract part of the enquiry could be directly used to test the student’s ideas and intuitions about the concrete question they were being asked.
In addition to this, we also observed how the technique worked for the less confident too. Those that were not sure how to answer the ‘domino theory’ question, and therefore responded to the teacher’s invitations with silence, were able offer something if he followed this up with the more general question, ‘So, are there any good reasons to go to war?’ and then, (iffing and ‘inferencing’) ‘So if X is a good reason to go to war what does that mean, if anything, about whether the domino theory is a good reason to go to war?’
So, using the Hokey Kokey Method, philosophy doesn’t have to be a discrete part of your week, squeezed in among all the other things competing for space; nor does it have to be that session where the discussions are great but with little or no application. Philosophy enquiries should be seamlessly integrated into your normal teaching; your good teaching.
Further reading
For more on the Hokey Kokey Method: https://bloomsburyeducation.wordpress.com/2016/02/02/peter-worley-why-use-stories-for-doing-philosophy-with-children/
For more on ‘iffing, anchoring and opening up’: https://kcl.academia.edu/PeteWorley
For more on Visual Thinking Strategies: http://www.vtshome.org/what-is-vts
Posted by on 20th September 2016 at 12:00am
Category: Philosophy, P4C, Education
Comments
Helpful post. Reminds me of something I read on my site: Gbetssa.co.za. What do you think?
Posted by Thorsten on 2nd October 2025 at 09:25pm
(eptx092@gmail.com) Buy Gamma-butyrolactone Gbl WhereTo Buy Gbl, GBL for salewhere to buy gbl in australia, where to buy gbl in anada,where to buy gbl,can you buy gbl in australia,gbl alloy wheel cleaner (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) Buy 99.9% GBL \ GHB Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale in Australia (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) GBL Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale Australia (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) GBL Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale Australia (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) GBL Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale Australia (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) GBL Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale Australia Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Buy Crystal Meth Online Europe - Buy 3MMC - 4MMC Crystals for sale - Buy Research chemicals for sale. We ship discreetly & stealth to individuals & medical Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Buy tramadol mephedrone,oxycodone,Xanax,Methadone,morphine, ketamine, 4-MMC, MDPV, methylone, amphetamine and more. Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Buy Research chemicals 4-MMC for sale online in Europe - trusted vendor. Buy cheap stimulants and 4-MMC, pay with Bitcoin and Crypto. Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Buy 4MMC Mephedrone - We are #1 supplier of Stimulants where you can order 4 MMC online in USA, Canada, UK, Australia.HIGH QUALITY 4MMC MEPHEDRONE. – Energy Control laboratory tested at 99% – High quality – Pure and uncut! 5 Grams – 4MMC Pre-Ban Mephedrone quantity. We are committed to helping customers worldwide with their unique needs by offering them comprehensive and professional service, enjoying a good reputation among our business partners and customers for high quality products, excellent customer service, competitive prices and prompt delivery. We maintain the highest standards not only in the production of our own products but also in the selection of all products we add to our range. We have many years of experience in this industry and have built a reputation as one of the most trusted suppliers in the UK, Europe and the world. Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Buy Research Chemicals Ephedrine hcl JWH-018 2fdck Apvp 3cmc Alprazolam Bromazolam Clonazolam Powder Protonitazene 2CB Mdphp Freebase Buy 5cladba 5cl online (Signal: +1(530)505-4406) Buy 5cl-adba, ADBB, APVP, Eutylone crystal, Jwh-018 / Jwh210, 2fdck, Isotonitazene,Fluetizolam, Bromazolam, Protonitazene, Metonitazene Hot-sale products: 5cl-adba precursor (semi finished ) 5cl-adba raw materials ADBB precursor (semi finished ) ADBB raw materials APVP powder Eutylone crystal ADBB raw materials Jwh-018 / Jwh210 2fdck New (small and big crystal) Isotonitazene cas 14188-81-9 Fluetizolam CAS: 40054-88-4 Bromazolam CAS: 71368-80-4 Protonitazene (hydrochloride) CAS: 119276-01-6 Flubrotizolam CAS: 57801-95-3 Metonitazene CAS: 14680-51-4 We specialize in exporting high quality Research chemical, medical intermediate, Pharmaceutical chemicals and so on. Products are exported to USA, Canada, France, Korea, Japan, Russia, Southeast Asia and other countries. Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home) Germany,bestalloy wheel cleaner Europe,allo wheel cleaner ebay uk,alloys wheels clean up,best alloy wheel cleaner uk,bl alloy wheelcleaner USA,best alloy wheel cleaner uk 2021,buy gbl online inaustralia,where to buy gbl in australia,gamma butyrolactone for sale,gamma btyrolactone home depot,where to buy gbl cleaner,how to clean the alloy wheel,alloy wheel cleaner used drug,alloys wheels clean up,best alloy wheel clener Ireland,can you buy gbl in australia?buy gbl cleaner,buy gbl in canada, by gbl in australia,where to buy gbl in canada,best place to buy gbl, buy gb online usa,where to buy gbl,buy gbl bitcoin,buy gbl,buy gbl online, buy gblin europe, buy gbl cleaner in australia,buy gbl wheel in cleaner, buy gl in uk,where to get gamma butyrolactone,products that contain gamma butyrlactone,gamma butyrolactone sold in usa,gamma butyrolactone cleaner,where to buy gbl cleaner,gbl alloy wheel cleaner Germany,best alloy whel cleaner Europe,alloy wheel cleaner ebay uk,alloys wheels clean p,best alloy wheel cleaner uk,gbl alloy wheel cleaner USA,best alloy wheel leaner uk 2021,alloy wheel cleaner ebay UAE,good alloy wheel cleane Australia,bute drugbute drugbute drugbute drugbute drugbute drugbute drug We sell high-quality products from the best producers. Offered goods are available in the warehouse. Shipments are very well packed. Shipment is always realized at the express pace. We are a legally operating company.bute drugbute drugbute drugbute drug You always get a receipt or invoice for the goods purchased.bute drugbute drugbut drugbute drugbute drugbute drugbute drugbuy bute drugbute drugbutedrug Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home) (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Toronto, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Saskatchewan, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Ontario, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Quebec, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Calgara, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Saskatchewan, Canada (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in New york, USA (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in San Francisco, USA (eptx092@gmail.com) Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in London, UK (eptx092@gmail.com) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Hobart, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Adelaide, Queensland (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin innBrisbane, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin Darwin, Australiabuy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Sydney, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Bendigo, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in East Gippsland, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Echuca, Australian (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) buy Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Geelong, Australia Gamma-butyrolactone(GBL) with bitcoin in Echuca, Australian, China, New Zealand, Qatar Dubai UAE Malaysia Oman Kuwait Bahrain Saudi Arabia #Singapore #Jordan #Ireland, #Belgium, #United Kingdom, #Iceland, #*Portugal, Spain, China, Japan, Turkey, Canada United States, Morocco, France, Germany, Poland Serbia, Romania, Ukraine, and all countries United Arab Emirates, Columbia, Columbus, United States Canada United Kingdom Australia Spain Italy France Germany Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Buy weed in Dubai, Buy weed in Abu Dhabi, Buy weed in Sharjah, Buy weed in Ras Al Khaimah, Buy weed in UAE Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Buy Weed, Cocaine, Heroin and Shrooms in France, Germany, Poland Serbia, Romania, Ukraine Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Buy Weed, Cocaine, Heroin and Shrooms in Dubai UAE Malaysia Oman Kuwait Bahrain Saudi Arabia Qatar (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) where can i find weed, cocaine, hash, mdma in dubai as a tourist? weed, cocaine, has, cystal, mdma for sell in uae, dubai, saudi arabia, qatar, oman, kuwait where to get good qulity weed, cocaine, hash, crystal mdma online in dubai, uae, ajman, abu dhabi Buy weed in Dubai, Buy weed in Abu Dhabi, Buy weed in Sharjah, Buy weed in Ras Al Khaimah, Buy weed in UAE, Buy weed in Al Ain, Buy weed in Umm al-Qaiwain, Buy weed in Fujairah, Buy weed in Ajman, Buy weed in qatar buy weed in jeddah buy weed in saudi arabi buy weed in riyadh buy weed in iraq buy cocaine in dubai buy cocaine in abu dhabi buy cocaine in saudi arabia buy cocaine in sharjah buy cocaine in kuwait buy cocaine in bahrain buy cocaine in iraq buy cocaine in fujairah buy cocaine in ajman buy cocaine in oman buy cocaine in qatar where can i buy weed, cocaine, hash, xanax, cbd oil, mdma in dubai, uae, abu dhabi where can i find cocaine in uae/ dubai buy any of this products Mdma-capsules for sale Nembutal for sale Xanax bars for sale Adderall for sale Fentanyl for sale Methadone for sale Benzedrine for sale Insulin for sale Diclofenac for sale Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home) They supply good quality Research Chemicals,Benzodiazepines, Pain pills,etc. Buy Fentanyl Online, your Trusted Source for Medical Supplies. Buy Fentanyl Online, Buy A-PVP Online, Buy Acetyl Fentanyl Powder Online, Buy Carfentanil Online, Buy 4-MMC Online, BUY AMPHETAMINE ONLINE, Buy xanax online, Buy Crystal Meth Online, BUY FENTANYL POWDER ONLINE , BUY ALPRAZOLAM POWDER ONLINE , BUY CARFENTANIL ONLINE , Buy A-PVP Online , Buy U-47700 Online , Buy Crystal Meth Online , BUY AMPHETAMINE ONLINE , Buy Clonazolam Online , BUY DICLAZEPAM POWDER ONLINE , Buy ketamine online , Buy Acetyl Fentanyl Powder Online , BUY APAAN ONLINE , Buy Diclazepam Online , Buy Etizolam Powder Online , Buy MDAI Online , Buy NM-2201 Online , Buy THJ-2201 online , BUY 5-METHYLETHYLONE ONLINE , BUY 4F-PV10 ONLINE , BUY 3-CMC CRYSTAL ONLINE , Buy 3-MMC Online , Buy Dibutylone online , Buy JWH-018 Online , Buy 4-MEC Online , Buy Mephedrone online , BUY MA-CHMINACA ONLINE , Buy Ephedrine HCL Online , Buy Oxycodone Powder online , Buy Cocaine Online BUY HEROIN ONLINE Buy Alpha-PHP Online Buy 4-Cl-PVP Online Buy 4-iBuF crystals Online Buy 5-EAPB Powder Online Buy 5-Meo-DMT Online Buy 5F-AMB Powder Online Buy 6-APB Online BUY 4-MMC ONLINE Contact info below WhatsApp:+1(215)-824-5074 Text:+1(530)-505-4406 Signal:+1(530)505-4406 Zangi:(16-3621-4477) Telegram:(@bubba_factory42) Email:(eptx092@gmail.com) Website:(sites.google.com/view/high-quality-bubba-kush-strain/home)
Posted by (Signal:+1(530)505-4406) Buy 99.9% GBL \ GHB Gamma Butyrolactone Chemical for sale in Finland on 12th February 2026 at 08:40pm