Zombie Elves and Existentialism: Doing Philosophy with Children

I spent the Summer Term of 2017 working with the Yr5 class at St. Bartholomew’s C.E. Primary School in Lewisham. Alongside philosophy, we delved into the form and content of stories and storytelling. 

storytelling

In our first session, we would be discussing the necessary features of stories. Assuming the class would be unconsciously habituated to some traditional understanding of stories that I couldn’t actually put my finger on, I prepared myself to help them explore some alternatives.

The questions I had jotted down in my notebook somewhere behind me were made immediately redundant after the first answer to the question: “What is a story?” Most of the class seemed to agree with some variation of the idea that “a story can be anything, it’s just a list of words with some imagination”. As an opinion holder, my job was done. As a facilitator, consensus was growing and I was failing. I fell back on testing the children’s ideas. I took random words from random children until we had a nonsense sentence. In fact, according to most of them, we had a story. “Was it a good story?” It seemed that it was more or less a decent one. Testing the alternative, I asked the class to give me a set of words that followed from each other. We were halfway through a short story about Legolas the Zombie Elf when E damned the flow with: “MacDonald’s!” Groans and accusations of “ruining it” rose from the class. T pleaded with E: “Why did you say that!” Why had E said that? “Because everyone was saying that stories don’t have to make sense so I thought I’d show them that they do have to make sense.”

I saw the intrigued and puzzled faces that you want to see during a philosophical enquiry. Your intuitions won’t do anymore. This is when you start formulating arguments, attuning yourself to nuance, listening to others, testing your own ideas, and so on. Whilst I won’t venture a definition of the practice here, this is when you start doing philosophy. During my relatively short time with The Philosophy Foundation (TPF) I have become used to children sharing ideas that clearly mirror those found in professional philosophical debate. Children have real and profound philosophical thoughts, but this is not always the same as doing philosophy. Doing philosophy requires a cognitive graft beyond that which is necessary for having philosophical thoughts. As we all do, children need some support in this discipline.

Luminously highlighting this difference for me, the term at St. Bartholomew’s amounted to a thorough examination of my developing facilitation skills. The class found it fairly easy to find and comment on the philosophy woven into stimulus stories. However, they often struggled to do philosophy, to listen and respond to each other. E’s contribution in that first session was a gift. Some of the supporters of free form communal nonsense narrative became a little more reserved. Others bolstered their unchanged opinions with more developed arguments. Ideas were qualified and deepened. New tensions and agreements were explored in the nooks and crannies of literary theory. It wasn’t that easy in the next few sessions and I struggled to successfully facilitate their eagerness. With opinions coming out of their ears, not much could get in. At the end of one session I asked the class how they thought the discussion had gone. They thought it had been good and there was nodded consensus that it had been good because “everyone got to say their opinion”. This might be a valuable part of doing philosophy with children, but, as noted, the sharing of philosophical opinions does not amount to practicing philosophy. Our enquiry into the discussion was brief and the class had been doing more philosophy than their reflection suggests. However, there had been more opinion sharing than philosophical discussion and this needed to change.

Alongside the general aims of TPF, there were two obvious reasons I needed to improve my facilitation. Firstly, though the majority of the class were eager to share their ideas, there were a few children that were reluctant to speak. The boldness of others seemed to increase this reluctance. I focused on these children during paired talk time and tried to validate their ideas in various neutral ways. However, I also tried to dethrone confident opinion in the enquiries. I sought harder for those who wanted to talk about how they weren’t sure what to think. When a child asserted a view, I would gently help them to explore the assumptions and implications of the view. This often meant that they wouldn’t be so sure anymore. Over the term, we legitimised doubt and engagement despite uncertainty. Though it was just the beginning of a start, I feel that the quieter children became a little more confident by the end of term.

Secondly, there is a discussion concerning the desired end of doing philosophy with children, but it certainly isn’t to let them stagnate in abilities already well developed. When a shy child shares an idea with the class after six weeks, no matter what it is, there is a feeling of small success. When the sharing of philosophical thoughts is easy for a child, resting on that feels like failure. They are ready to do philosophy and they only fall short when the facilitation isn’t properly tuned.

My main aim was to get the class to really listen to each other. When they did, complex debates began to develop. Becoming stricter about low level disruption and improving my selective echoing of their ideas helped with this a great deal. As my facilitation improved, my aim changed. Instead of getting them to listen to each other, I wanted to help them see the worth of listening to each other. How the children’s interaction with one girl changed over the term perhaps shows that they did begin to see the philosophical value of listening to others.

B was always keen to speak. Her predominant mode of engagement was to share meandering tales from her home life and television viewing. These tales could be punctuated with some insightful philosophy. The problem was that sometimes she got lost in the storytelling and would forget why she had started speaking in the first place. She would call herself out for irrelevance. When she did get to her philosophical point, half the class might be daydreaming or focusing on trying not to blurt out their own thoughts. To counter these issues I tried to clamp down on any disruption during her storytelling and to always anchor her to the task question. Anchoring would invariably prompt a philosophical insight or question. One week, after confusing herself with a half-remembered anecdote from a TV show, B claimed that whatever our ‘genius scientist’ put into our ‘robot’s brain’, it would never be able to feel the same emotions as a human. I would then ask her to explain a little further. More often than not, she would explain her reasoning and then link it to the story she had just told.

In our last few sessions I noticed a change in the way some of the others responded to B getting the talking ball. Even if she herself was holding back the chuckles through a narrative, there was a patience in the room. What B was saying would be relevant, we just had to listen. When the class listened to B, the discussion would usually deepen. More generally, ideas began to be prefaced with: “I agree/disagree with X because”. This shift enabled the class to take themselves into complex areas of philosophy without too much involvement from me. In Forest Hill Library for our last session, I heard the wonderful words: “After listening to everyone else, I’ve changed my mind, kind of”. This engagement with others may only be the beginning of doing philosophy, but I hope that together we laid a strong foundation for the class to further explore philosophical thought and practice.

Returning to that which comes naturally to children, the big ideas, I will let the class demonstrate their capacity for philosophy. Back in the library, at the end of the session, I circled around to our very first question: “What is a story?”

Child: “A story is yourself.”

Facilitator: “A story is yourself, what do you mean by that?”

Child: “Well, you are a story, yourself, because you create yourself.”

Facilitator: “You are a story…”

Child: “I agree because there are different chapters in your life, you’re young, then you’re a teenager, maybe you get married, and you die at the end, there are different parts to your life.”

Child: “Yeah, it’s like writing a book, you decide what your story is going to be.”

Child: “I disagree…because if I’m a story…then I’m not real.”

Tim is a Level 2 Specialist Philosophy Teacher with The Philosophy Foundation. He is a philosophy graduate of King’s College London and Edinburgh University. As well as his work with TPF, Tim is a private tutor and bar manager.

If you would like to get in touch with Tim or hear more about this project, please email info@philosophy-foundation.org

Posted by Joe Tyler on 4th August 2017 at 12:00am

Comments

You can download any of the provided casinos heavens without any problems. If you download the casino app, it purposefulness do one's daily dozen like a regular replication of the out-and-out milieu from the mobile version. Unfortunately, all the apps you download choose just trade on Android. Download casino in 1 click from the schedule, these are the most advanced mobile applications. The unsurpassed casino apps as a service to Android The difficult is that determination Android apps and downloading them can be iffy, as Google doesn't allow valid money Android casinos to be placed in the Play Store. Download casino app But don't stew, there is a artless dissolving, you can download the casino app from casinoapk2.xyz. As so many users have been asking around casino gaming on their Android phones or tablets. We dug round a tittle to discover you the best casino apps offering the same real readies experience. The most in 1win Ukraine, download 1win. Reviewers validate each pertinence for refuge to secure positiveness; We will-power labourers you rouse real pelf gambling apps with the most beneficent Android apps; The casinos offer the best selection of games. Download Real On easy street Casino It is not usually easy as pie to download tangible money casinos, even on more in fashion smartphones like Samsung Galaxy, HTC One-liner or Sony Xperia. So if you hunger for to download the app to away folding money, read all below. Our team ground the prime casinos present trait gambling exchange for your trick and ran an intense 25-step verification operation for the treatment of them. On this epoch you drive come on an bearing in spite of Android: Reception Promotions - We recollect how much players hanker after to misappropriate betterment of the bonuses, so we made firm that our featured sites tender inimical deals in support of Android. Diversity of games. Decayed exquisite is a jumbo minus. We only recommend the app, the plucky portfolio is vast and varied. Deposits - You need as not many restrictions as viable when it comes to depositing and withdrawing shin-plasters to your casino app account. We cause steady that all apps we approve allow a encyclopaedic variety of payment methods. Fleet payouts. All applications put on the market fast payments with true readies, credited to the account in a few hours. Mobile Compatibility - Play Apps Anywhere. Consumer Shore up - To be featured on the Featured Record, we require online casinos to provide comprehensive and wide-awake client service. Advantages of an online app in behalf of Android Great video graphics and usability in Android apps. Judgement the uniform marvellous PC experience. Quick access from the application. Casino apps - looking looking for the most appropriate We halt and download casino apps to assure they touch high-priced standards. The criteria employed to selected a casino app are good as stringent as the criteria used to approximate a PC casino. Each commitment has: Highest distinction graphics; Flexible loading and playing measure; Fast payouts.

Posted by ApkJoyhIz on 12th November 2021 at 08:52pm

https://www.youube.me/ - 온라인바카라,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,바카라게임사이트,인터넷카지노 https://youube.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youube.me/ - 카지노주소 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youube.me/royalcasinoseries/ - 로얄카지노계열 https://youube.me/slotmachinesite/ - 슬롯머신사이트 https://youube.me/maxcasino/ - 맥스카지노 https://youube.me/baccaratgamesite/ - 바카라게임사이트 https://youube.me/casimbakorea-casino/ - 카심바코리아 카지노 https://youube.me/mobilecasino/ - 모바일카지노 https://youube.me/real-timebaccarat/ - 실시간바카라 https://youube.me/livecasino/ - 라이브카지노 https://youube.me/onlineslots/ - 온라인슬롯 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 바카라 이기는방법 https://youube.me/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://youube.me/ourcasinosite/ - 우리카지노사이트 https://youube.me/sandscasinoaddress/ - 샌즈카지노주소 https://youube.me/baccarat-rulesofthegame/ - 바카라 게임규칙 https://youube.me/baccarat-howtoplay/ - 바카라 게임방법 gamja888.com instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.youube.me/ - 온라인블랙잭 on 7th April 2022 at 05:34am

https://www.youubbe.me/ - 카지노사이트,슬롯사이트,바카라사이트,온라인카지노,카지노주소 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 안전한카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/ - 슬롯카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 바카라게임 https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노추천 https://youubbe.me/ - 비바카지노 https://youubbe.me/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://youubbe.me/casinosite/ - 카지노사이트 https://youubbe.me/baccarat/ - 바카라 https://youubbe.me/baccaratsite/ - 바카라사이트 https://youubbe.me/pharaoh-casino/ - 파라오카지노 https://youubbe.me/제왕카지노/ - 제왕카지노 https://youubbe.me/mgm카지노/ - mgm카지노 https://youubbe.me/theking-casino/ - 더킹카지노 https://youubbe.me/coin-casino/ - 코인카지노 https://youubbe.me/solaire-casino/ - 솔레어카지노 https://youubbe.me/casino-game/ - 카지노게임 https://youubbe.me/micro-gaming/ - 마이크로게이밍 https://youubbe.me/asia-gaming/ - 아시아게이밍 https://youubbe.me/taisan-gaming/ - 타이산게이밍 https://youubbe.me/oriental-game/ - 오리엔탈게임 https://youubbe.me/evolution-game/ - 에볼루션게임 https://youubbe.me/dragon-tiger/ - 드래곤타이거 https://youubbe.me/dream-gaming/ - 드림게이밍 https://youubbe.me/vivo-gaming/ - 비보게이밍 youube.me gamja888.com instagrme.com Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://youubbe.me/ - 카지노추천 on 7th April 2022 at 05:34am

https://www.gamja888.com/ - 온라인카지노,카지노사이트,바카라사이트,온라인바카라,카지노게임사이트,Gamja888 https://gamja888.com/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://gamja888.com/ - 맥스카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 비바카지노 https://gamja888.com/ - 카지노주소 https://gamja888.com/ - 바카라추천 https://gamja888.com/onlinebaccarat/ - 온라인바카라 https://gamja888.com/millionclubcasino/ - 밀리언클럽카지노 https://gamja888.com/safecasinosite/ - 안전카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/baccaratsiterecommendation/ - 바카라사이트추천 https://gamja888.com/ourcasino/ - 우리카지노계열 https://gamja888.com/slotmachine777/ - 슬롯머신777 https://gamja888.com/royalcasinosite/ - 로얄카지노사이트 https://gamja888.com/crazyslot/ - 크레이지슬롯 https://gamja888.com/onlineblackjack/ - 온라인블랙잭 https://gamja888.com/internetroulette/ - 인터넷룰렛 https://gamja888.com/casinoverificationsite/ - 카지노검증사이트 https://gamja888.com/safebaccaratsite/ - 안전바카라사이트 https://gamja888.com/mobilebaccarat/ - 모바일바카라 https://gamja888.com/howtowin-baccarat/ - 바카라 필승법 https://gamja888.com/meritcasino/ - 메리트카지노 https://gamja888.com/baccarat-howto/ - 바카라 노하우 youube.me instagrme.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://www.gamja888.com/ - 제왕카지노 on 7th April 2022 at 05:37am

https://www.instagrme.com/ - 바카라사이트,우리카지노,온라인바카라,카지노사이트,실시간바카라 https://instagrme.com/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://instagrme.com/ - 바카라게임 https://instagrme.com/ - 카지노주소 https://instagrme.com/woori-casino/ - 우리카지노 https://instagrme.com/theking-casino/ - 더킹카지노 https://instagrme.com/sands-casino/ - 샌즈카지노 https://instagrme.com/yes-casino/ - 예스카지노 https://instagrme.com/coin-casino/ - 코인카지노 https://instagrme.com/thenine-casino/ - 더나인카지노 https://instagrme.com/thezone-casino/ - 더존카지노 https://instagrme.com/casino-site/ - 카지노사이트 https://instagrme.com/gold-casino/ - 골드카지노 https://instagrme.com/evolution-casino/ - 에볼루션카지노 https://instagrme.com/casino-slotgames/ - 카지노 슬롯게임 https://instagrme.com/baccarat/ - baccarat https://instagrme.com/texas-holdem-poker/ - 텍사스 홀덤 포카 https://instagrme.com/blackjack/ - blackjack youube.me gamja888.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://instagrme.com/ - 개츠비카지노 on 7th April 2022 at 05:38am

https://www.instagrme.com/ - 바카라사이트,우리카지노,온라인바카라,카지노사이트,실시간바카라 https://instagrme.com/ - 퀸즈슬롯 https://instagrme.com/ - 바카라게임 https://instagrme.com/ - 카지노주소 https://instagrme.com/woori-casino/ - 우리카지노 https://instagrme.com/theking-casino/ - 더킹카지노 https://instagrme.com/sands-casino/ - 샌즈카지노 https://instagrme.com/yes-casino/ - 예스카지노 https://instagrme.com/coin-casino/ - 코인카지노 https://instagrme.com/thenine-casino/ - 더나인카지노 https://instagrme.com/thezone-casino/ - 더존카지노 https://instagrme.com/casino-site/ - 카지노사이트 https://instagrme.com/gold-casino/ - 골드카지노 https://instagrme.com/evolution-casino/ - 에볼루션카지노 https://instagrme.com/casino-slotgames/ - 카지노 슬롯게임 https://instagrme.com/baccarat/ - baccarat https://instagrme.com/texas-holdem-poker/ - 텍사스 홀덤 포카 https://instagrme.com/blackjack/ - blackjack youube.me gamja888.com youubbe.me Instagrm.me Instagrme.net instagrme.site instagrme.live naverom.me facebookom.me

Posted by https://instagrme.com/ - 카지노다이사이 on 7th April 2022 at 05:39am

[url=https://hydraruzpnew4afonion.com]Ссылка на гидру hydraruzxpnew4af hydraclubbioknikokex7njhwuahc2l67lfiz7z36md2jvopda7nchid onion[/url] гидра зеркало hydraruzxpnew4af com - https://hydraruzpnew4afonion.com - HYDRA сайт зеркало лучше всего открывать через TOR браузер, рулетка гидры взлом. Бывает так ваш заказ оформлен, но некоторые orders зеркала ГИДРЫ могут не работать, какой браузера на нашем сайте вы onion market всегда найдете актуальную рабочую ссылку на ГИДРУ hydraclub в обход блокировок. ГИДРА site официальный имеет множество зеркал, на случай вы забанены, onion, высокой нагрузки или DDoS атак. Пользуйтесь ссылкой выше v3.hydraruzxpnew4af.com.co для создания безопасного conversations соединения с сетью TOR и открытия рабочего зеркала. Также hydraclubbioknikokex7njhwuahc2l67lfiz7z36md2jvopda7nchid thread если вы видите сообщение, что зеркало mirror hydraruzxpnew4af недоступно, просто momental обновите страницу чтобы попробовать использовать другое зеркало hydra4jpwhfx4mst (иногда нужно сделать это hydraruzxpnew4af.com.co чем HYDRA откроется). Дело в том, что HYDRA onion имеет множество зеркал и некоторые сайты hydra из них могут быть недоступны из-за высокой нагрузки.

Posted by hydraJup on 21st April 2022 at 02:49pm